Purple Hearts - Broken Brains


|


CCN Series Blog

Purple Hearts - Broken Brains

Troops and Vets

UPDATE: Be sure to visit Paul Rieckhoff's Blog at the Huffington Post entitled "Adding Insult To Injury"

“The PURPLE HEART is awarded to members of the armed forces of the U.S. who are wounded by an instrument of war in the hands of the enemy and posthumously to the next of kin in the name of those who are killed in action or die of wounds received in action. It is specifically a combat decoration."

At the Polytrauma Unit of the VA medical center in Palo Alto, we meet four patients who are working to put their lives back together. (1)

Jay struggles to pick up a paper clip. His responses and speech are slowed; he cries easily.

Claudia can't remember giving birth to her 2-year old daughter and needs pictures in her room to remember her family. She uses a PDA as a "memory prosthesis" and says "My memory's not in my head any more, it's in my hands."

Frank's speech is slurred, and he needs a wheelchair to get around. He must wear a helmet to protect his brain, left vulnerable when his skull was badly damaged.

Eric must monitor carefully what he says and does because his injury impaired the part of his brain responsible for impulse control. Since his injury, he's had to re-learn how to speak and how to walk and he still needs help with coordination and simple skills like getting into a car.

These veterans must relearn everyday things that we take for granted. Not all of them bear obvious wounds, such as a lost eye or a missing part of a skull, but all share in common serious injuries to their brains.(2)

Traumatic brain injury (TBI) has been called the “signature injury” of the Iraq war. Despite improved body armor, the head remains vulnerable and with the preponderance of explosive devices used in the war, brain injuries are a common result. With improved and swift medical care close to the front, many injuries that once would have been fatal have been survived.

Some brain injuries are obvious – those resulting from shrapnel, debris or gun shots penetrating the skull into the brain. These types of penetrating injuries have occurred in previous wars.

Other types of brain injuries, sometimes called “closed injuries”M/i> are more specific to explosions and vehicular crashes.

The brain is injured by the force of impact when it moves within the skull. It may suffer concussive injury (bruising) and/or the axons of nerve cells may be twisted, stretched or broken. For a good explanation of the mechanisms of brain injuries, check How the Brain is Hurt from a guide to brain injury survival written for patients and their families.

Severe injuries may result in coma for indefinite time periods. These are readily diagnosed and can be further differentiated with CT scans. As with injuries to other parts of the body, swelling and bleeding is a typical response to trauma. But because the skull provides a hard cover around the brain, there is little space for the brain to swell or for blood to accumulate. The only outlet is the opening at the base of the skull. If swelling is not relieved quickly, the brainstem, which controls breathing and cardiac function, will be compressed, resulting in death. In these cases, surgery is done immediately at combat support hospitals to reduce the impact of swelling – frequently by removing a part of the skull temporarily. (The resected part of the skull is typically stored in the patient’s abdomen until it can be safely replaced.)

The injuries are sometimes so severe that neurosurgeons in one of the combat hospitals say that if they saw such injuries in the States, they would consider them non-survivable and not perform surgery. However, in Iraq, they do the surgeries no matter how severe the injuries, in hopes of getting the patients out of the war zone to enable the families to see them at least one more time. (3)

For those patients who do survive beyond the first few days, the recovery period is likely to be very long and slow, with uncertain outcomes. The period of coma, or minimal responsiveness, can last for months , during which time they’re completely dependent for all their physical needs, including respiratory and nutritional support and extensive care measures to prevent complications from extended immobility.

And for those whose responsiveness does eventually begin to improve, there can be significant medical, functional and cognitive hurdles to overcome.

  • When the brain is not providing the necessary controls over muscles and coordination, swallowing may be severely impaired, placing patients at risk of aspiration.
  • Control of bowel and bladder function is typically impaired.
  • Extremity muscles may remain tightly flexed because of the inability of the brain to mediate the necessary balance between stretching and contracting, leading to a condition called spasticity. Conversely, some muscles may receive no signals from the brain and become limp. Both conditions complicate mobility and other basic tasks of daily living.
  • Additionally, the injured brain is far more prone to seizures.
  • Vision may be impaired because of disruption of the nerve pathways from the eyes to the brain.
  • The motor coordination needed for speech may be impaired as well as the cognitive capacity for communication.
  • Blood pressure, heart rate, and even functions such as metabolism and temperature regulation can be affected.

Less severe injuries may not be apparent - especially those that involve minimal or no loss of consciousness. The victim may have other more obvious and serious injuries requiring emergency treatment, or may not have any visible injuries at all. In the latter case, troops are often returned to active duty without intervention. Their deficits may be subtle and, if noticed, may be attributed to post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Symptoms of brain injury can overlap those of PTSD. Some troops may be suffering from both conditions. Changes in performance may be attributed to bad behavior or attitude problems.

Someone with a mild or moderate brain injury may feel an undefined sense of “cloudiness”, loss of short-term memory, slower response times, quicker temper, difficulty focusing, decrease in physical coordination or balance, seizures – a myriad of symptoms, depending on exactly what parts of the brain are affected. In some cases, it’s not until a soldier returns home, and family notices changes in behavior and personality, that a diagnosis is made and proper treatment can be initiated.

Whether severe or mild, when troops suffer TBI's, the impact on their families is significant. For those with severe injuries, family members might have to give up jobs to devote full time to care giving. For those with milder injuries, families must learn what problems are precipitated by the injuries and make adjustments in how they relate. The service member affected may have deficits that prevent doing the type of job he/she previously held, contributing to economic pressures on the family as well as the effects that such losses have on self-image and family roles.

Over the next few weeks, we'll meet some of the troops and families who've been affected by brain injuries. The first will be the four veterans introduced above, who were featured in a recent documentary produced by the PBS series California Connected :



War Stories from Ward 7-D

Jason Poole is another young veteran of the Iraq war, also treated for TBI at the Palo Alto facility. His story was documented in a story called The Hidden Epidemic by a UK television reporter. This is the video from that story:



The Hidden Epidemic

Submitted by testvet6778A on September 5, 2006 - 10:33am.

have been prevented by DOD paying 100 dollars for the helmet adaption kits that families and willing people have been funding across America, I hope Rummy and co-horts are truly ashamed over this...

SSG M G Bailey disabled vet Army 73-82 and Gulf War 1

jen's picture
Submitted by jen on September 5, 2006 - 3:49pm.

as I read this, testvet. It's impossible to imagine how when they were spending all the effort and money in improved body armor, that it didn't occur to anyone that they were missing one very important piece of protection??? WTH?

Thank you Troops & Vets.

Once in a while you get shown the light, In the strangest of places if you look at it right. - Hunter/Garcia


LJM's picture
Submitted by LJM on September 5, 2006 - 10:51am.

I did part of my training at that VA in Palo Alto in the 70s. They were a state of the art place then and suspect they still are. When I was there Max Cleland was the head of the VA system.


Submitted by Sybil Liberty on September 5, 2006 - 2:08pm.

I can hardly speak tho, after reading this one. Maybe later....

...fascist is, as fascist does, mr. preznit

Submitted by msbehavinforclark on September 5, 2006 - 2:43pm.

I have no words either.

Submitted by Pilgrim on September 5, 2006 - 5:08pm.

Another editorial about the unconscionable cut in the budget for the Defense and Veterans Brain Injury Center:

Traumatic Cut

With so many troops in harm's way, now is no time to cut the budget of the Veterans Brain Injury Center.

-- snip --

Of 18,000 troops injured in Afghanistan and Iraq, as many as 10,000 may have suffered some brain injury, estimates Stuart Hoffman, a brain injury researcher at Emory University.

More. . .

* * * *
IAVA has posted an action item on their website to help in contacting newspapers and Congressional reps. It was also included in one of their recent newsletters.

carol4clark

General Wes Clark * * * * 4 Stars Over Texas

Submitted by Nelsons on September 5, 2006 - 8:08pm.

another reminder of the sacrifices being made by our troops and their families on our behalf. And as TestVet6778A pointed out, in many cases the injuries could have been preventable.

Thank you Troops & Vets for a very impactful article.

Proud to be an American.

Submitted by ms in la on September 5, 2006 - 8:36pm.

--another needed look at what they keep trying to hide from the citizens who are funding this war.

Troops and Vets team-- you are really performing an important service in this ... well, I wanted to call it this 'War on Misinformation', but let's say in this era of blacked out press where the real story so often goes buried or at best disguised. You are consistently making us look at these real albeit painful stories-- introducing the people who are behind the sterile numbers released by the DOD.

Broken Brains.

Broken Hearts.

Thanks so much for this, once again!

Submitted by Pilgrim on September 6, 2006 - 10:23am.

Hooley demands better helmets for troops in Iraq

Representative Darlene Hooley has proposed a bill in Congress that would require the Department of Defense to reimburse soldiers serving in Iraq who choose to purchase helmet padding that is superior to their standard-issue equipment.

“This is one of those issues that makes my blood boil,” said Hooley. “The Defense Department decided to lower the standards that they use for helmet padding in November 2004.”

-- snip --

She explained that the protective padding that soldiers wear inside their helmets is rated for the amount of force that it transfers to the wearer’s head during an explosion – measured against the force of Earth’s gravity, known as g-force. The higher the number, the less protection the padding provides.

“The old standard was 150 g-forces on the helmet, but the Defense Department raised that to 300 g-forces,” said Hooley. “At that 300 g-force rating, if you get hit in the head, you’re dead. At the 150 g-force level, you probably have a brain injury.”

Continuing, Hooley added that elite special forces soldiers are provided with helmet padding rated at 90 g-forces, and the price difference between that and the 300 g-force padding being provided to regular troops is modest – only $20 to $30 per set.

“I don’t understand it – it makes no sense,” Hooley said. “I am appalled that they would do this.”

--snip--

“It costs between $600,000 and $5 million to treat a brain injury.

“If you outfitted the 150,000 troops we have in Iraq right now with the best available padding, it would cost $4.5 million. This whole thing could pay for itself by preventing one injury.”

She was quick to add that her calculations made no allowance for the human suffering that accompanies brain injuries, and which will often affect soldiers for the rest of their lives.

Another inexplicable policy from an administration that claims to support the troops. Please help make your Congressional representatives and/or candidates aware of this issue, and encourage them to speak out about it along with the issue of funding for the Veterans Brain Injury Center.

Meanwhile, until the Pentagon does what they need to do, we can help by supporting Operation Helmet.

carol4clark

General Wes Clark * * * * 4 Stars Over Texas

Submitted by Nelsons on September 6, 2006 - 12:05pm.

Thank you for pointing people to a way that they can help prevent or lessen brain injuries for our troops.

Proud to be an American.

Submitted by justcallmeOHIO on September 6, 2006 - 3:03pm.

for our troops on Tues.

I blogged about it here
http://securingamerica.com/ccn/node/8320

With each new revelation I just feel the knot of anger growing tighter and tighter in my heart.

I just can't understand...I just can't.

Submitted by Pilgrim on September 6, 2006 - 3:18pm.

Putting these outrages together with the stories Paul Rieckhoff tells in his book about the equipment shortages and inadequacies, not to mention the shortage of troops during the time when they could have made a difference. . .

How can they keep singing the same tune and not realize how offkey they are?

carol4clark

General Wes Clark * * * * 4 Stars Over Texas

Submitted by justcallmeOHIO on September 6, 2006 - 3:36pm.

They just keep hopin' we won't notice.

We're noticing and they're busy calling us traitors and Nazi's instead of doing anything that might actually CORRECT the problems.

I've been reading Paul's book...and yes, that too adds to the anger and sick feeling in my soul.

These are our precious children, fathers, mothers, sisters and brothers that they so casually throw onto the dung heap.

Beyond my comprehension...just too much.

Submitted by ms in la on September 6, 2006 - 7:28pm.

I'd asked Paul if he might read this Troops & Vets entry and perhaps link to it at his blog, and here what he said;
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Hey ms,

We’d be happy to link to it your TBI entry on our blog this week. Great segment. Please let Daniel (at IAVA) know about future entries. Also, please check out my piece today on TBI and cross post where you can:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/paul-rieckhoff/adding-insult-to-injury_b_28840.html

Thanks to you (and Keith) for all your support! We are grateful.

Best,

Paul.

Paul Rieckhoff

Executive Director and Founder

IAVA: Iraq & Afghanistan Veterans of America
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

So go check out Paul's TBI entry at HuffPo (<---who recently came up with that ingenious idea of doing "Series Blogs"...) ;P

Good to know that at least the bloggers have this covered. Good to know that somebody cares about these issues. Even if the Media don't seem to feel it has priority... : (
Please link to Paul's entry as well as ours wherever you can.

Submitted by ms in la on September 7, 2006 - 9:02pm.

It's the second story on the IAVA site at this link:

http://www.iava.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=blogsection&id=14&Itemid=161

Congratulations!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.